Review: Six Wild Crowns (Queens of Elben, #1) by Holly Race
As I approached Six Wild Crowns, I was filled with hope. Fantasy worlds offer such tantalizing escapes, and the allure of a new tale unfolding in the kingdom of Elben was too tempting to resist. Holly Race, a debut author, was inviting readers to explore her imaginative landscape, blending politics and romance in a way that could spark a reading renaissance. However, my experience was a mixed bag, leading me to ultimately step away halfway through. Yes, it’s a somewhat damning conclusion—but there’s a flicker of promise in the ashes.
At its core, Six Wild Crowns attempts a daring melding of political intrigue, romance, and history. The narrative is primarily driven by Anne Boleyn, a character steeped in historical complexity, and her relationships with other notable figures of the era. Race captures the essence of courtly life, peppering her plot with castles and romance that promise a riveting storyline. There’s an undeniable rhythm in her prose that keeps the plot moving, a refreshing departure from some recent reads that felt dense and sluggish.
Yet, this elegance in writing doesn’t compensate for the shortcomings in world-building and historical authenticity. The geographical representation of Elben feels strangely flat and devoid of the nuance that real-world politics and boundaries would provide. It occasionally tips into an unwelcome orientalist overview that feels more like a sketch than a fully realized world. For instance, the conflicts intrinsic to the era—tied to religion and race—remain ghostly figures lurking just out of reach. It’s as if Race set out to capture the vibrancy of Tudor England but pulled back, leaving behind mere echoes instead of the richness one would expect from a historical fantasy.
The romances, both heterosexual and queer, felt underdeveloped. This isn’t an indictment of Race’s intent to include diverse representations; rather, it’s clear that romance may not be her strong suit. The characters traverse love and longing in a manner that feels more obligatory than passionate. Perhaps this is where my frustration lies—I truly wanted to connect with these characters but found them to be mere reflections of better-defined narratives.
A notable moment in the book that sparks interest is Race’s approach to religion and its intersection with power dynamics. However, instead of diving into this criticism with depth, it feels somewhat glossed over. In a period where belief was intertwined with every facet of life, the absence of genuine exploration leaves the characters feeling devoid of the hardships and motivations that might have made them more relatable. There’s potential here, which only further highlights my disappointment at Race not fully engaging with these fascinating themes.
Despite my frustrations, I recognize the ambition behind Six Wild Crowns. If nothing else, it serves as a reminder of what one should consider when writing fantasy rooted in history: curiosity. Unfortunately, in a literary landscape that teems with creativity and digital access to a plethora of resources, it appears Race might have missed an opportunity to flesh out the rich tapestry of women’s stories she seeks to tell.
In closing, I would recommend Six Wild Crowns to readers who enjoy light fantasy with historical references, perhaps those looking to dip their toes back into the genre without holding it to the rigorous standards that established authors have set. While my experience was not entirely fulfilling, I genuinely believe that Holly Race possesses a spark waiting to be ignited through more research and subsequent works. It’s a journey worth embarking on, albeit one that might require patience and a bit of hope.
Discover more about Six Wild Crowns (Queens of Elben, #1) on GoodReads >>