Book Review: Powerless (The Powerless Trilogy, #1) by Lauren F. McKellar
When I first picked up Powerless, I was drawn in by the promise of grand stakes set in a world reminiscent of beloved titles like The Hunger Games and Red Queen. The premise of the story hit just the right notes for me—the tension of survival, a dash of romance, and a morally ambiguous hero to swoon over. However, I quickly learned that sometimes the most enticing covers conceal a script that still needs some serious editing (and oh, how I longed for an editor!).
From the get-go, we meet Paedyn Gray, our protagonist who is anything but a dull character. She embodies that classic "not-like-other-girls" trope, filled with sass and a sharp tongue, but she sometimes feels more akin to a caricature than a fully fleshed-out character. I initially appreciated her fierce spirit, yet found myself rolling my eyes as the pages unraveled more of her predictable arc. She wades through a myriad of clichés, navigating a realm of societal divides, secret trials, and a love triangle that had all the depth of a kiddie pool. It’s an ambitious setup, but it often trades originality for familiarity.
As for her love interest, Kai, he hits the tall, dark-haired, brooding hero mark perfectly. However, I couldn’t help but feel disappointed by his lack of true moral complexity. Far too many moments seem engineered for melodrama rather than depth; his "morally grey" demeanor sometimes comes off as just plain bland. Unlike Katniss Everdeen or even Mare Barrow, whose struggles felt visceral, Kai often seemed to exist solely to rekindle the tired romance trope.
The writing is where Powerless strayed the most for me. It felt as though I were reading a rough draft with frequent typos and an overabundance of long-winded sentences that left me more bewildered than enchanted. The repetition—how many times can we hear about “blue eyes” or “ocean eyes”?—was tiresome, transforming moments of tension into an endless loop of clichés. And heavens, the pacing! It was so slow that I half-expected to see it rusting on the bookshelf.
Yet, I have to admit, there were some moments of genuine delight. The banter, while clunky at times, offered glimpses of charm. I found myself chuckling at Kai’s overly cheesy lines, much like one might laugh at a solidly cringe-worthy romcom. It struck me that this book could serve as a playful satire on the very tropes it indulges in.
Ultimately, Powerless left me feeling conflicted. I appreciated the nod to familiar narratives but couldn’t shake the feeling that it could have ventured into deeper, more innovative territory. However, if you’re someone who devours romantasy novels with dramatic flair and aren’t overly concerned about originality, this book might scratch that itch. Perhaps it speaks to its intended audience more than it did to me—the nostalgic reader yearning for a fresh spin on existing tales.
In conclusion, Powerless is like a guilty pleasure kiss from a crush you know you shouldn’t have. It has its sparkly moments, but if you’re looking for a complex narrative or groundbreaking storytelling, you might want to temper your expectations. For those who revel in the classics with a side of fluff and glitter, this one is certainly worth a read. And who knows? In the grand tapestry of dystopian romances, it might just find its place alongside the other well-worn titles we love.
Discover more about Powerless (The Powerless Trilogy, #1) on GoodReads >>