Book Review: He Who Fights with Monsters: Book Twelve by Shirtaloon
Ah, the lure of a beloved series, where anticipation is a heady mix of excitement and dread. When I cracked open He Who Fights with Monsters: Book Twelve, I was met with that familiar world crafted by Shirtaloon—a space I’ve journeyed through for years. But I couldn’t shake off the thought: would this book finally address the pacing and narrative choices that have nagged at me since Book Nine? Spoiler alert: it partially does.
Shirtaloon’s latest installment gives us something I’ve been longing for—a time jump! After spending six books in the ouch of silver grade, witnessing our protagonist’s slow climb through a series of contrived foes, I cheered as we shifted gears. The promise of fresh narrative terrain piqued my interest. However, as I immersed myself in this new landscape, I felt an unsettling sense of déjà vu. While the time jump had potential, what unfolds feels more like filler than a thrilling entry in a power fantasy series.
The book offers exposition-heavy storytelling that meticulously chronicles the escapades of a forgettable cast. Instead of allowing us, the readers, to glean information organically, we are spoon-fed character developments that seem unnecessary. Wouldn’t it have been better to embrace the suspense of the unknown? Imagine jumping into a vibrant world filled with new characters and a tantalizing mystery about the old ones—now that would have struck a chord!
Another element that struck me was the extensive cultural commentary threaded through the narrative. I found myself pondering if Shirtaloon has momentarily strayed from the core of progression fantasy. While I appreciate a well-executed literary touch, in a genre where escapism and power dynamics reign, I couldn’t help but feel this deviation weighed down the story. Yes, the age-old battle of good versus evil is a tried-and-true trope, but it felt disappointingly mundane in this context.
And, oh—let’s talk romantic relationships. The dynamics read like they were penned by someone who’s never truly engaged in the messy tapestry of real-life emotions. The romantic arcs bubble with a palpable awkwardness, reminiscent of a middle-school crush rather than mature connections. It’s particularly jarring in a world teeming with stakes and action, leaving the reader wondering if they were meant to cheer for these couples or cringe at their interactions.
Despite these frustrations, I must acknowledge a silver lining—this book is certainly not without merit. I appreciated the attempt at broadening the narrative landscapes and the unique twists that surfaced. However, its role feels more like a setup for what’s to come than a fulfilling journey in its own right.
In conclusion, He Who Fights with Monsters: Book Twelve may resonate with loyal fans looking for a glimpse into the author’s evolving narrative style, but it’s a mixed bag. For newcomers, I’d recommend starting earlier in the series to truly appreciate the world and the characters. While I found myself grappling with some significant flaws, I can still appreciate the unique escapism this series offers. With a sigh and a hopeful heart, I look forward to what comes next—hopefully, a more engaging and solid arc grounded in progression fantasy’s best pillars.
Discover more about He Who Fights with Monsters: Book Twelve (He Who Fights… on GoodReads >>