Book Review: Before Dorothy by Hazel Gaynor
As a long-time admirer of Hazel Gaynor’s work, I was thrilled to dive into her latest novel, Before Dorothy. The allure of exploring the backstory of beloved characters like Dorothy and Aunt Em from The Wizard of Oz intrigued me. I’ve often wondered about Dorothy’s life before her iconic journey to Oz, and Gaynor’s wonderfully crafted narrative promised to unravel those mysteries in a poignant way.
In Before Dorothy, Gaynor transports us to 1932, where we meet Emily Gale, Aunt Em herself, as she grapples with the loss of her sister, Annie. Suddenly thrust into the role of guardian for seven-year-old Dorothy, Emily’s internal conflict shines through. She hasn’t seen Dorothy since infancy, and the emotional weight of that relationship—coupled with her strained connection to her sister—offers a stunning backdrop against which the story unfolds. The dual timelines, shifting between the present and flashbacks to 1924 Chicago, allow us to intimately grasp the complexities of family bonds, migration, and the pursuit of dreams in the face of adversity.
One of the standout elements for me was the way Gaynor grounds this story in a beautifully realistic setting, far removed from the whimsical adventures we associate with Oz. Emily’s experiences as she and her husband, Henry, begin their new life on the Kansas prairie are depicted with exquisite detail. Gaynor paints a vivid picture of their initial optimism, which is soon tempered by the harsh realities of the Great Plains. The encroaching hardships of the Dust Bowl—overexploitation of land, devastating droughts, and economic struggles—add a layer of depth that resonates powerfully in today’s context of environmental concerns.
Gaynor’s writing style is both lyrical and accessible, balancing rich descriptive passages with engaging dialogue that propels the narrative forward. I found myself rooting for Emily, admiring her resilience as she navigated her new role and formed a bond with Dorothy. And while they aren’t at the forefront, references to familiar elements of The Wizard of Oz—like the scarecrow, tin man, and tornado—are woven seamlessly into the fabric of the story, providing delightful nods for those in-the-know, yet remaining relatable for newcomers.
One quote that particularly resonated with me was Emily reflecting on family: “In the midst of sorrow, we find unexpected joys.” This sentiment encapsulates the novel’s heart, showcasing how love and hope can flourish even in life’s bleakest moments.
Ultimately, Before Dorothy is more than just a spin-off; it’s an evocative exploration of family, resilience, and the stark realities of life in a tumultuous era. I would recommend this book not only to fans of The Wizard of Oz but to anyone who appreciates historical fiction that dives deep into the human experience. Hazel Gaynor has delivered a touching story that lingers long after the final page, inviting us to consider how our past shapes our futures.
If you’re looking for a vibrant tale filled with emotion, adventure, and a touch of nostalgia, Before Dorothy might just be the perfect read. I know it will stay with me for some time, a gentle reminder of the layers of story that shape our lives.