Review of Between Earth and Sky by Amanda Skenandore
When I picked up Between Earth and Sky, I was drawn in by the heart-wrenching premise and the promise of a rich historical narrative. Amanda Skenandore’s debut novel, exploring the dark legacy of Native American residential schools through the eyes of a lonely girl, seemed like a compelling blend of heart and history. Little did I know, I was about to embark on a poignant journey that would linger in my thoughts long after the final page.
At the core of Skenandore’s narrative is Alma Mitchell, a young girl in early 20th-century Philadelphia, whose life becomes intertwined with the haunting past she tried to escape. The story unfolds through Alma’s childhood at Stover School, a boarding school created to “assimilate” Native American children, and her adult life as she grapples with a shocking crime involving her childhood friend Harry Muskrat. The dual timelines expertly peel back layers of secrecy and trauma, revealing the deep scars left by colonialism and forced assimilation.
The themes of friendship, betrayal, and the sacrifices made for belonging resonate powerfully throughout the novel. Skenandore doesn’t shy away from exploring the painful truths of history, and her vivid prose gives life to the harsh realities faced by individuals caught between two worlds. It’s impossible not to feel the weight of Alma’s struggle as she grapples with her identity and the consequences of her father’s misguided mission.
One particularly poignant moment captures Alma’s realization: “They obliterated everything that mattered to these children.” It’s a line that echoes the heart of the book, emphasizing the emotional cost of cultural erasure. Skenandore’s ability to weave historical context with familiar human experiences creates a novel that’s both heart-wrenching and deeply engaging.
The writing style stands out as a breath of fresh air. Skenandore’s prose is both lyrical and sharp, maintaining a pace that pulls readers into the emotional tapestry of the characters’ lives. Each chapter unfolds like a page in history, immersing us in lush descriptions of the past while never losing the thread of Alma’s internal conflict. Her vivid details, such as the sun “beating off their beautiful brown skin,” invite readers to visualize and feel, fostering a connection to the characters that is both intimate and profound.
For readers who enjoy historical fiction with a socially conscious lens or those who appreciate complex character studies, Between Earth and Sky is a must-read. It challenges us to confront uncomfortable truths while also reminding us of the enduring nature of love and friendship against the backdrop of adversity.
This novel has left an indelible mark on me, illuminating a chapter of American history that often slips through the cracks of mainstream discourse. It’s a story of pain, but also of resilience, understanding, and the pursuit of justice—a reflection on how far we’ve come and the miles still left to travel. I couldn’t recommend it more highly; Skenandore’s work is not just a book to read, but an experience to be felt.